[Denied] Suggestion - Remove the rule and Event Staff election

killer_king wrote:Good suggestions

KuRuMi^ wrote:I recommend the staff member who makes applications under discussion should provide the result of what the applicant lacked before denying. However, it's great that we don't receive any complaints from the applicant or others therefore leading in the development of this rule was a great option. -1

Pavonis wrote:

KuRuMi^ wrote:I recommend the staff member who makes applications under discussion should provide the result of what the applicant lacked before denying. However, it's great that we don't receive any complaints from the applicant or others therefore leading in the development of this rule was a great option. -1

We don't cos not everyone have time to do such things. If you want to deny it then tell us reason or for voting NO then tell us reason or how the hell we gonna know what to improve?

Umar4911 wrote:Today, I am 2 suggestions:

- Recently, admins made a new rule that admins have to vote in their board. By voting there, the player cannot get to know that what lacks him and cannot improve the problems until his next app. According to my suggestion, the rule should be removed.
Before the introduction of new admin rule, the admins use to vote "No, not ready yet". I want to suggest that they should tell the reason why he is not ready e.g. "No, not ready yet because new on forum"

- Same is the case with event staff. The applier cannot get to know about the opinion of event staff members and what is he lacking.

Chuck Norris wrote:

Umar4911 wrote:Today, I am 2 suggestions:

- Recently, admins made a new rule that admins have to vote in their board. By voting there, the player cannot get to know that what lacks him and cannot improve the problems until his next app. According to my suggestion, the rule should be removed.
Before the introduction of new admin rule, the admins use to vote "No, not ready yet". I want to suggest that they should tell the reason why he is not ready e.g. "No, not ready yet because new on forum"

- Same is the case with event staff. The applier cannot get to know about the opinion of event staff members and what is he lacking.

The admins are required to vote in the application as well. But yes we should disclose the reasons if we haven't done so.

ЧК. wrote:The staff will give you feedback if it's necessary. Actually you are supposed to apply when you are completely ready, progress made during the application progress is not really convincing because you feel you weren't ready when you posted the app. You need to be completely ready when you apply, and when denying the app staff will give you feedback if needed.

It is better to discuss in private because admins can vote with more freedom knowing their vote is anonymous and it will also prevent applicants for fighting with admins over votes and useless arguments.

Chuck Norris wrote:

Umar4911 wrote:Today, I am 2 suggestions:

- Recently, admins made a new rule that admins have to vote in their board. By voting there, the player cannot get to know that what lacks him and cannot improve the problems until his next app. According to my suggestion, the rule should be removed.
Before the introduction of new admin rule, the admins use to vote "No, not ready yet". I want to suggest that they should tell the reason why he is not ready e.g. "No, not ready yet because new on forum"

- Same is the case with event staff. The applier cannot get to know about the opinion of event staff members and what is he lacking.

The admins are required to vote in the application as well. But yes we should disclose the reasons if we haven't done so.

They're not.

Pavonis wrote:

ЧК. wrote:The staff will give you feedback if it's necessary. Actually you are supposed to apply when you are completely ready, progress made during the application progress is not really convincing because you feel you weren't ready when you posted the app. You need to be completely ready when you apply, and when denying the app staff will give you feedback if needed.

It is better to discuss in private because admins can vote with more freedom knowing their vote is anonymous and it will also prevent applicants for fighting with admins over votes and useless arguments.

Chuck Norris wrote:

Umar4911 wrote:Today, I am 2 suggestions:

- Recently, admins made a new rule that admins have to vote in their board. By voting there, the player cannot get to know that what lacks him and cannot improve the problems until his next app. According to my suggestion, the rule should be removed.
Before the introduction of new admin rule, the admins use to vote "No, not ready yet". I want to suggest that they should tell the reason why he is not ready e.g. "No, not ready yet because new on forum"

- Same is the case with event staff. The applier cannot get to know about the opinion of event staff members and what is he lacking.

The admins are required to vote in the application as well. But yes we should disclose the reasons if we haven't done so.

They're not.

What if someone thinks he is perfect for it now. But for some reasons admins deny it and didn't even told what's the reason, then what? Also, we should be able to ask why cos we have created the topic and we have the right to post there and ask why vote no. And that will contain as a spam? Players spamming good luck everywhere and we just asked an important question and its get spam? And why would be there a argue? The guy just asked the reason of vote and he will tell the reason and here its end and even if they argue so what? They are just discussing themselves none else needs to get in it. I think this rule SHOULD be removed.

ЧК. wrote:The staff will give you feedback if it's necessary. Actually you are supposed to apply when you are completely ready, progress made during the application progress is not really convincing because you feel you weren't ready when you posted the app. You need to be completely ready when you apply, and when denying the app staff will give you feedback if needed.

It is better to discuss in private because admins can vote with more freedom knowing their vote is anonymous and it will also prevent applicants for fighting with admins over votes and useless arguments.

Chuck Norris wrote:

Umar4911 wrote:Today, I am 2 suggestions:

- Recently, admins made a new rule that admins have to vote in their board. By voting there, the player cannot get to know that what lacks him and cannot improve the problems until his next app. According to my suggestion, the rule should be removed.
Before the introduction of new admin rule, the admins use to vote "No, not ready yet". I want to suggest that they should tell the reason why he is not ready e.g. "No, not ready yet because new on forum"

- Same is the case with event staff. The applier cannot get to know about the opinion of event staff members and what is he lacking.

The admins are required to vote in the application as well. But yes we should disclose the reasons if we haven't done so.

They're not.

HaseeB^ wrote:

ЧК. wrote:The staff will give you feedback if it's necessary. Actually you are supposed to apply when you are completely ready, progress made during the application progress is not really convincing because you feel you weren't ready when you posted the app. You need to be completely ready when you apply, and when denying the app staff will give you feedback if needed.

It is better to discuss in private because admins can vote with more freedom knowing their vote is anonymous and it will also prevent applicants for fighting with admins over votes and useless arguments.

Chuck Norris wrote:

Umar4911 wrote:Today, I am 2 suggestions:

- Recently, admins made a new rule that admins have to vote in their board. By voting there, the player cannot get to know that what lacks him and cannot improve the problems until his next app. According to my suggestion, the rule should be removed.
Before the introduction of new admin rule, the admins use to vote "No, not ready yet". I want to suggest that they should tell the reason why he is not ready e.g. "No, not ready yet because new on forum"

- Same is the case with event staff. The applier cannot get to know about the opinion of event staff members and what is he lacking.

The admins are required to vote in the application as well. But yes we should disclose the reasons if we haven't done so.

They're not.

Mate you mean our admins are shy or they have fear, that the applicant will start fighting or admins are shy to vote negative to their friends? If it is so, then this new format is fine.
BTW -1 for the suggestion. #HaQ